Should Notre Dame Get A Makeover?

A massive fire engulfed Notre Dame Cathedral during Holy Week in 2019.  In the aftermath, a variety of perspectives on its reconstruction emerged.

Some embrace a recreation of the iconic building exactly as it was. Others are open to a more contemporary design.

Some want the same materials to be used. Others advocate fire-resistant materials.

Some push for a rapid reconstruction. Others favor a patient, methodical approach.

The need to balance art, science, emotions, and even politics make this reconstruction project especially challenging.


Video Spotlight: Numerous ideas to rebuild Notre Dame


This post is based on the Post-Gazette article, Notre Dame Cathedral’s Reconstruction Sparks Architectural Design Debate, by D. Majors, April 21, 2019; and the YouTube video, How Notre Dame Might Be Redesigned and Rebuilt, by Now This News, April 29, 2019. Image source: Bill Perry/Shutterstock

Discussion Questions:

1. What are the pros and cons of using wood to rebuild the roof of the cathedral?

Guidance: According to Mr. Cullen, the roof has to be rebuilt with wood to achieve the grandeur of the original structure. No other material could reproduce the same beauty. However, there are no more trees tall enough to replace the wooden beams.

Furthermore, the attic was often referred to as “the forest,” and it indeed burned like a forest. The collapse of the thrust from the roof could have put the entire stone structure at risk.

To prevent a future disaster of this magnitude, unsightly sprinklers would have to be incorporated into the structure and made to look as unobtrusive as possible.

2. Should the cathedral be rebuilt within five years? Could unlimited funds help in this endeavor?

Guidance: French President Emmanuel Macron is pushing for the very short time frame of five years. Several experts find it unrealistic. Although speed is encouraged, hurriedness is not an option for an iconic building visited by millions of tourists every year.

More than a $1 billion have been pledged for the reconstruction, but reconstruction cannot start until the full extent of the damage has been determined and the building has been deemed safe. This could take up to five years. In other words, if budgeting issues are not a primary constraint, the complex initiation and planning phases of the project could delay a speedy reconstruction.

3. What are the main hurdles perceived in managing this project?

Guidance: Performance objectives may be difficult to achieve because of the unavailability of some of the materials (e.g. tall oaks) and talent (e.g. wood carving; masonry) used in the original construction. Behavioral issues may be even more problematic as resistance to change and adversarial politics (e.g. Macron’s adversaries advocate an exact replication of the centuries-old building) hinder the planning and execution of this project. Finally, the uncertainty about activity times will likely compound the challenges.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Carrot Straws?
Dressed for Success in the Gaming World