Auto Industry’s Relationships With Chip Suppliers
Previous OM in the News posts have looked at the chip shortage and automotive production, and how Tesla, for one, is responding. We’re back with an update.
Semiconductor shortages go beyond an increase in demand for autos, port slowdowns, and other pandemic-related issues.
Part of the problem is that the auto industry traditionally has dealt with their suppliers in such a way as to allow short-term changes to their orders. Whereas most chip makers want guaranteed orders for a couple of years.
Another issue is that the chips used for autos are an older style. It doesn’t make sense for the chip makers to invest in obsolete equipment to produce these chips. Chip makers are suggesting that auto manufacturers redesign cars to use a more modern chip, and in the meantime, their capacity for the older chips can’t keep up with demand. Now that they’ve fallen behind on deliveries, it will be more difficult for semiconductor manufacturers to catch up.
For products using more modern chips, the chip manufacturers are adding capacity, an that will result in catching up to the demand for these chips.
One further complication: Just-in-Time (JIT) has long been an auto industry standard. It offers many advantages, especially when demand is stable and there are few disruptions in the supply chain. However, an over-reliance on low inventory levels became an issue as COVID-related issues disrupted the supply chain, which has also contributed to the chip shortage.
Video Spotlight:
- General Motors to increase vehicle deliveries amid global chip shortage (June 3, 2021, Click on Detroit | Local 4 | WDIV)
- Expect fewer options at the dealership as chip shortage disrupts auto industry (Oct 11, 2021, Washington Post)
This post is based on the Detroit News article, Chip Crisis Forces Rethink of Just-In-Time Ordering, by Ian King and Keith Naughton, May 28, 2021; the Teslarati article, Tesla’s Rise Amid the Chip Shortage Shows A Dire Need for Innovation in The Auto Sector, by Simon Alvarez, October 5, 2021; and the YouTube videos in the Spotlight. Image source: Jenson/Shutterstock.
Discussion Questions:
1. Should auto manufacturers change how they deal with chip suppliers?
Guidance: Auto makers are used to being the “800 pound gorilla.” When dealing with suppliers, they normally get what they want. The problem is that for chip manufacturers, only 40% of their business comes from the auto industry. This is substantial, but not a dominant portion of their business. Many auto makers are working on their relationship with their existing chip suppliers to insure a steady supply of chips.
2. Should the auto industry discontinue JIT?
Guidance: JIT has tremendous advantages. It is unlikely that auto manufacturers will abandon JIT. The past year or two has stressed supply chains, especially the auto supply chain. A combination of weather-related issues, combined with pandemic-related problems, have caused substantial disruptions. Problems continue as different regions of the world are impacted differently and at different times by the pandemic.
Many supply chains have been impacted. However, the auto industry’s supply chain has been hit hard. Part of the issue is the global nature of its supply chain. The longer the supply chain, the more likely that a local event can cause a disruption. Adding to the disruption is the dependent demand nature of auto manufacturing. A shortage of one part can shutdown the manufacturing process. Couple this with lean inventory, and these disruptions can have substantial impact.
Auto manufacturers appear to be treating the disruptions as part of their JIT approach. The pandemic has stressed the auto supply chain, now auto manufacturers are looking to remove these problems from their supply chain. If they manage it, their supply chains will become more resilient.
3. What would you recommend auto manufacturers do to prevent future shortages of chips and shutdowns of their facilities?
Guidance: COVID-19 and weather issues have stressed auto supply chains, pointing out areas for improvement. Many automakers are looking at ways to prevent future chip shortages, and are considering a variety of approaches. These include joint ventures, bringing chip manufacturing in-house, holding additional inventory, and redesigning to use different chips.
Further, the U.S. government is looking at bringing chip production to the United States. This would increase overall capacity, and shorten the supply chain for domestically-produced vehicles.
4. Why would auto manufacturers use obsolete chips?
Guidance: Older style chips are more of a commodity item. As a result, they are less expensive than chips that are state of the art. Another consideration is that automobiles present a greater safety risk than, say, a smart phone. Auto manufacturers are cautious about design changes to insure customer safety. This impacts how quickly they can make changes in design.
An additional related matter are safety and environmental (e.g., fuel economy) regulations. Auto manufacturers must ensure that any design changes meet all regulatory requirements, which slows down changes in product design.





