Are You a “Problem Returner”?

Retail returns are a problem for many retailers. In 2023, over $743 billion in merchandise was returned.

It can cost 40% of the value of an item to process the return to be resold. And in many cases, items can’t be resold for full price. As a result, many retailers are looking at their return policies and making changes to them.

These changes include shrinking the return window, charging for returns, allowing customers to “just keep it,” and in some cases denying returns.

As part of the return process, many companies are using The Retail Equation score to determine how to handle returns for individual customers. The Retail Equation score is generated by tracking returns. A variety of stores are using the score, including Best Buy, T.J. Maxx and Home Depot.

The Retail Equation does state that a customer’s score is only based on transactions for the specific store that is using it.

For some retailers, a poor score can override the standard return policy. It can even prevent returns from customers with poor scores for a year.


Video Spotlight:  


This post is based on the CNBC article, How Retailers Like Best Buy, T.J. Maxx And Home Depot Quietly Target ‘Problem’ Returner, by Devin Burris, May 10, 2024, and the YouTube video in the Spotlight. Image source: Sergey Yechikov/Shutterstock

Discussion Questions:

1. Do you know your Retail Equation score?

Guidance: Answers will vary. Many people will not even know that their returns are being tracked, let alone their score.

2.  Should retailers deny returns based on a poor score on The Retail Equation?

Guidance: Most people will not have a problem with stores denying inappropriate returns as long as appropriate returns are easy to obtain. The issue is in correctly identifying what is an inappropriate return. Making returns difficult for legitimate return customers can negatively impact sales.

3. What other approaches should retailers use to reduce returns?

Guidance: The best approach is to not have returns. Retailers should do everything they can to have the product satisfy customers. Obviously, selling good quality products helps.

Next, it is important that the customer understands what product they are receiving. In-person shoppers may rely on employees to help with product selection. Therefore, employees need to be well trained and knowledgeable about the products. For online shopping, a detailed and accurate product description helps, including good photos and accurate customer reviews. Some online retailers are looking at generative AI to help guide customers to the best product match.

Although retailers seek to reduce or eliminate returns, they are inevitable. When a return happens, retailers want to make returns easy for legitimate returns, but want to deny inappropriate or even fraudulent returns. Fraudulent returns include the return of stolen merchandise. In some cases, retailers are working together to insure the provenance of returned products, and prevent the return of stolen goods.

The issue is how to identify the type of return. One approach is changing return policies to make inappropriate returns difficult. Recent policy changes include reducing the return window, charging a fee for returns, telling customers to “just keep it,” and only allowing returns for specific reasons, such as defective items or inaccurate product descriptions.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
July 8, 2024 Newsletter
CosMc's Loyalty Program